Shiny Shag Rock

I've had a dilemma tonight, knowing which image to Blip! The one that's in Extra was such a fun 'happening'. The young girl had been eating fish & chips, first out on the far rocks, and then at a bench near the beach. Each place she'd been sharing her meal with the gulls - hence the pic in Extras.

The one I've blipped, of Shiny Shag Rock, is such a common scene for me. Somehow this image is different from others I've taken, and I'm wondering how it will seem to you. I love the shafts of light coming down from the clouds, and it seems to be making Shag Rock shine. It looks as though it's a mono, but actually is a colour photo which just looks B&W. 

I wonder which one you'd have blipped?