Two Consecutive Shots, Two Different Opinions!

Would it surprise any one of you who follows me that my husband I had a difference of opinion on which shot should be my entry for the Wide Wednesday challenge of "Skyscape".?  It shouldn't----we've only been married for forty years!  I have put the other shot in the extras and I'm not saying whose preference is which   Which one would you have chosen?  Thanks to BobsBlips for hosting.....