Help needed..........

........as we had a camera club challenge today to take images at a specific place (Hillarys Marina) in a specific time. Then we have to enter one image at the next meeting in April. So........which one? This one or my extra?? 
Please.......  ;-)))
The extra is just a rope mooring but I quite like the starbursts on the water. 

I might add I was brave (for me) capturing this bloke